[r-t] Exceptions to the Extension Rules
Richard Smith
richard at ex-parrot.com
Tue Nov 23 16:38:38 UTC 2004
Sorry for not replying sooner to this, Graham.
Graham John wrote:
> Richard Smith wrote:
>
> > According to the CC e-collection I downloaded on Friday,
> > there are 239 (non-Little) Surprise method names that
> > have been used on more than one stage.
>
> This is useful Richard. Could you add which stage is invalid because where a
> method is named at more than one stage, it is often only one of these which is
> invalid e.g. Bristol Major, Superlative Minor.
>
> In due course, it would be good if the MC could add the extension type (or a
> note describing an anomaly) as a new field on the method libraries.
Does the attached table cover these two requests?
The string "xxx" represents an invalid or illegal extension.
(Sometimes, e.g. with Beverley's underwork, it could still
be given a proper name even though it is illegal. I have
described these with "xxx" too.)
Where a stage is given in parentheses, e.g. 14 for Feering,
it has not been named on that stage (or possibly has been
named differently) even though it is uniquely defined.
(I've omitted trailing lists of parenthetic stages.)
Most extensions can be described in many different ways. I
have arbitrarily chosen one way.
Chester and Wembley could both benefit from further
explanation:
Chester 6->8: xxx/xxx; 8->12: xxx/xxx
Wembley 8->10: 1FG/xxx; 10->12: 1FG/xxx; 12->16: 1FG/6GH
For Chester, the major version is the anomalous one. 6->12
is a perfectly good 2DE/5FG extension (and, indeed, an
indefinite one working on 6n bells).
For Wembley, the royal version is anomalous. 8->12->16 is a
again perfectly legitimate 1FG/6GH extension applying
indefinitely on 4n bells.
Richard
-------------- next part --------------
Albanian 10->12: 1AB/1HI
Aldenham 8->10: 1AB/xxx; 10->12: 1AB/1GH
Allendale 6->8: 1DE/3EF
Alloa 8->10: 1FG/6HI
Alnwick 6->8: 1AB/1EF
Amersham 8->(10)->12: 1DE/5FG
Annable's London 6->8: 1CD/1DE
Apsley 8->12: 1CD/1EF
Axminster 8->10: 1AB/1FG
Ballymena 8->12: 1FG/1GH
Bangor 6->8: xxx/xxx
Beangram 10->12: 1AB/1GH
Bedford 6->8: xxx/xxx; 8->10->12: 1EF/6HI
Belfast 8->12: 1DE/6GH
Belgrave 8->10->12: 1AB/1FG
Beodericsworth 10->12: 1CD/8JK
Berkshire 8->10->12: 1BC/1EF
Beverley 6->8: 1AB/xxx
Biddenden 8->10->12: 1AB/1FG
Birmingham 8->10: 1DE/3GH
Blackburn 8->10: 1FG/5GH
Bottesford 8->10: 1AB/1HI
Bourne 6->8->10->12: 1DE/4EF
Braunstone 8->10->12: 1AB/1FG
Bristol 8->10: xxx/xxx; 10->12->14->16: 1EF/1EF
Buckingham 8->12: 1EF/5GH
Cambridge 6->8->10->12->14->16: 1AB/1DE
Canterbury 6->8: 1BC/1EF
Carlisle 6->8->10->12: 1AB/1DE
Cat's-Eye 8->10: 1EF/5GH
Cheltenham 8->(10)->12: 1BC/1DE
Chester 6->8: xxx/xxx; 8->12: xxx/xxx
Chigwell Row 8->12: 1FG/5GH
Christchurch 8->10->12: 1AB/1FG
Clacton 8->10: 1FG/5HI
Clerkenwell 8->12: 1EF/1GH
Clifton 10->12: 1BC/1IJ
Cobham 8->10: 1FG/5HI
Concorde 8->10: 1CD/1GH
Conisbrough 8->12: 1FG/6GH
Cornwall 8->12: 1EF/5FG
Cotswold 8->12: 1BC/1GH
Countesthorpe 8->10->12: 1BC/1AB
Coventry 8->10: 1EF/4EF
Cray 8->12: 1EF/4FG
Cumbria 8->10->12: 1BC/1DE
Damgate 10->12: 1AB/1AB
Daresbury 10->12: 1EF/1FG
Devon 8->10->12: 1FG/5HI
Ditcheat Manor 8->10: 1FG/5GH
Dodford 10->12: 1BC/4AB
Dodleston 8->12: 1FG/5HI
Dorking 8->10->12: 1AB/1AB
Double Dublin 8->(10)->12: 1BC/1GH
Dougal 8->10: 1AB/1FG
Ealing 8->12->16: 1FG/5FG
Eastwood 6->8: 1AB/xxx
Elmodesham 8->(10)->12: 1DE/5FG
Elveden 8->10: 1FG/5FG
Enfield 8->(10)->12: 1EF/1FG
Essex 8->10->12: 1FG/5HI
Eves 8->12: 1DE/5GH
Evesham 8->10->12: 1BC/1FG
Ewerby 10->12: 1AB/1IJ
Feering 8->10->12->(14)->16->18->20: 1DE/4EF
Folgate 8->12: 1EF/5FG
Foxley 6->10: xxx/xxx
Fryerning 6->8: 1DE/3DE
Fulham 10->12->14->16: 1FG/4IJ
Goldsborough 10->12: 1BC/1EF
Grantham 6->10: xxx/xxx
Grundisburgh 8->10->12: 1DE/6HI
Halloween 8->10: 1AB/1GH
Halstead 8->10: 1FG/5GH
Hampshire 8->12: 1CD/xxx
Hampstead 10->12: 1AB/1HI
Hampton 8->10: 1AB/xxx
Harleston 8->12: xxx/3FGHI
Haslemere 6->10: xxx/xxx
Hatfield 6->8: 1AB/xxx
Hathern 6->8: 1DE/1FG
Havant 8->10: 1AB/1DE
Hexham Abbey 8->10: 1EF/5FG
Highclere 8->10: 4DE/7HI
Highclere Castle 8->10: 1BC/1GH
Holbeach 8->10: 1FG/6GH
Horsleydown 10->12: 1EF/1EF
Huddersfield 8->12: 1FG/6GH
Hughenden 8->(10)->12: 1DE/5GH
Humberside 10->12: 1AB/1GH
Ickleton 8->12: 1FG/6GH
Ilkeston 8->10: 1BC/1DE
Imperial 10->12: 1AB/1HI
Iodine 8->10: 1EF/5GH
Ipswich 6->8: 1AB/xxx
Isleworth 10->12: 1AB/6AB
Jawcraig 8->10: 1FG/5FG
Jedburgh 8->(10)->12: 1BC/1AB
Jersey 8->12: 1CD/1CD
Jubilee 8->12: 1FG/5HI
Kenninghall 8->10: 1EF/5FG
Kingwood 8->(10)->12: 1FG/5HI
LDG100 8->10: 1EF/5GH
Langley 8->10->12: 1EF/1GH
Leatherhead 8->(10)->12->14->16: 1FG/5FG
Leicestershire 8->10->12->14->16: 1EF/5FG
Leominster 8->(10)->12: 1EF/6HI
Lessness 8->12: 1FG/5GH
Lincoln 6->8: xxx/xxx
Lincolnshire 8->10->12->14->16: 1AB/1AB
Lindsey 10->12: 1AB/1JK
Lindum 8->12: 1FG/5HI
Londinium 12->16: 1DE/9KL
London 6->8: 1DE/1EF
London No.3 10->14: 1DE/9JK
Loughborough 6->8: xxx/xxx
Lufkin 8->10->12: 1FG/4GH
Luton 6->10: xxx/xxx
Lutterworth 8->(10)->12: 1FG/1FG
Lyme 8->10->12: 1AB/4AB
MM 10->12: 1AB/6AB
Manchester 8->(10)->12: 1EF/4FG
Melton 6->10: xxx/xxx
Midsomer Norton 10->12: 1DE/1GH
Minehead 6->10: xxx/xxx
Mortlake 8->10: 1AB/1HI
Mottram 8->12: 1EF/1GH
NUSCR 8->10->12: 1AB/1EF
National Trust Centenary 8->(10)->12: 1EF/5GH
New Cambridge 8->10->12: 1AB/1FG
New Durham 8->10->12: 1DE/4EF
New Gloucester 8->(10)->12: 1BC/1GH
Newcastle 6->8: xxx/xxx
Newgate 12->14->16->18->20: 1DE/9KL
Newport 8->(10)->12: 1DE/4HI
Norfolk 6->8: xxx/xxx
Northumberland 6->8->(10)->12: 1AB/1DE
Norwich 6->8->10->12: 1DE/4EF
November 8->10->12: 1EF/4FG
Oklahoma 10->12: 1AB/1AB
Old 8->10: 1FG/5GH
Old Superlative 8->10: 1AB/1EF
Old Trout 10->12: 1FG/5HI
Osgathorpe 8->10: 1AB/1FG
Oxfordshire 8->(10)->12: 1BC/1DE
Painswick 8->10: 1FG/5GH
Parkway 10->12: 1EF/1EF
Pontefract 10->12: 1AB/1GH
Portsmouth 8->10: 1DE/1DE
Preston 6->8: xxx/xxx; 8->12: 1EF/2GH
Primrose 6->8->10->12: 1BC/1DE
Prittlewell 10->12: 1BC/1FG
Promethium 8->10: 1DE/4EF
Pudsey 8->10->12->14: 1BC/1DE
Putney 8->10: 1AB/1FG
Quedgeley 8->10->12: 1AB/1FG
Quenby Hall 10->12: 1AB/6AB
Quethiock 8->(10)->12: 1FG/5GH
Redcliffe 10->12: 1EF/1FG
Renfrew 10->12: 1FG/6GH
Reverse Yorkshire 8->10: 1BC/1EF
Rickmansworth 10->12: 1AB/6AB
Ripon 8->10: 1FG/5HI
Rochester 6->8: xxx/xxx; 8->10->12: 1DE/6HI
Rushton 8->10: 1AB/1DE
Rutland 8->10: 1AB/xxx
Sawley 8->(10)->12->(14)->16: 1FG/4EF
Scawthorpe 8->10: 1FG/5GH
Scothorne 8->12: 1FG/5FG
Seaton 8->10: 1FG/5GH
Selborne 8->10: 1EF/5FG
Shropshire 8->12: 1CD/xxx
Silver 8->10: 1FG/5HI
Sleaford 6->8: xxx/xxx
Solihull 10->12: 1BC/1DE
Southern Cross 8->10: 1EF/1FG
Southwell 8->10->12: 1AB/1EF
Spalding 6->8: xxx/xxx
Staffordshire 8->10: 1BC/xxx
Stand 8->10: 1AB/1EF
Stansted Mountfitchet 8->12: 1FG/5HI
Stepney 8->10: 1AB/1EF
Storefield 8->10: 1EF/5GH
Stoughton 8->12: 1EF/5FG
Superlative 6->8: xxx/xxx; 8->12->16: 3ABCD/3FGHI
Surfleet 6->12: 1DE/5FG
Swindon 10->12: 1AB/1AB
Tattersalls 8->(10)->12: 1EF/5FG
Taylor 6->8: 1BC/4EF
Tellurium 8->12: 1EF/5FG
The Hundred 10->12: 1EF/1DE
Thorne 6->8: xxx/xxx
Tintwistle 10->14: 1FG/5FG
Tottington 6->8: 1CD/xxx
Trafalgar 8->12: 1FG/1FG
Trowbridge 8->(10)->12: 1DE/1FG
Turramurra 8->12: 1AB/1FG
Turvey 8->10: 1FG/7HI
Tyburn 8->10: 1BC/1HI
Uppington 10->12: 1EF/1EF
Upton 10->12: 1AB/4AB
Uttoxeter 6->8: xxx/xxx
Uxbridge 8->12: 1FG/5GH
Vermuyden 10->14: 1FG/5FG
Verulam 8->12: 1EF/4GH
Via Gellia 8->10->12: 1FG/6HI
Warkworth 6->10: 1DE/4EF
Warwickshire 8->10: 1DE/xxx; 10->12: 1DE/1FG
Water 6->8: 1DE/1EF
Wembley 8->10: 1FG/xxx; 10->12: 1FG/xxx; 12->16: 1FG/6GH
Westbury 8->10: 1DE/3GH
Westminster 6->8->10->12: 1DE/3DE
Weston 6->8: xxx/xxx
Wexham 10->12: 1FG/1DE
Whitehaven 8->10: 1FG/1EF
Whitley 6->8->10: 1BC/1DE
Whitwick 8->10->12: 1AB/4AB
Wigorniensis 10->12: 1BC/1IJ
Wigston 8->12: 1EF/5FG
Winchester 6->8: xxx/xxx; 8->10->12->14: 1AB/1FG
Withycombe Raleigh 8->10: 1CD/1EF
Woodspring 10->12: 1AB/1FG
Woodstock 8->10->12: 1BC/1FG
Worcester 10->12->14: 1FG/8IJ
Worcestershire 8->10->12: 1BC/1DE
Wordsworth 8->10: 1DE/xxx
Worsley 10->12: 1BC/4HI
Worthington 8->10->12: 1AB/1FG
Wycombe 8->10->12: 1AB/1EF
Wye 8->10->12: 1AB/1FG
XL 8->10->12: 1AB/1GH
Xavier 8->12: 1EF/5FG
Xenia 8->12: 1CD/1AB
Xenolite 8->10: 1EF/1GH
York 6->8->10->12->14->16->18->20: 1DE/4EF
Yorkshire 8->10->12->14->16: 1AB/1FG
Yoxall 6->(8)->10: 1AB/5FG
Zebedee 8->10: 1AB/1FG
Zelah 8->10->12: 1AB/1FG
More information about the ringing-theory
mailing list