[r-t] What people think they have rung
robin at robinw.org.uk
Tue Oct 21 05:22:01 UTC 2014
Isn't much of the recent discussion going back to the initial event
which caused this trouble? A band wanted to describe what they had rung
in their own way.
Think back to Don's point about learning Plain Bob. There are sometimes
many ways to learn a method (or a composition, even). Take Cambridge or
Yorkshire Royal - which will be the Surprise Royal *most* learn first.
One member of this list is a blue-line learner. I was taught to ring
them by the rules. There will be those who ring by place notation. (All
of us will have come across those who ring by 'space notation' - find a
hole and fill it.) Following the thread of the discussion, there could
be three different names, quite easily, for the same thing. (Does anyone
know the blue line for DNCB, I wonder?)
I called a quarter of PB6 on Saturday - nor did I? There is nothing to
stop me sending this up as Spliced Plain & Single St. Hilda.
Sometimes, life comes down to what most people will accept. Many of us
on this list will have some sort of mathematical background. What would
happen if a small minority decided to use different names for a group, a
ring or a coset? What is going on here is Mummersetshire thinking - 'we
always do this if it's the third Wednesday of five in a month with an R
in it'. For those of you with a medical background, what would happen if
one Medical school taught all diseases with different names?
Someone has to decide. A recent poll said it shouldn't be the Methods
Committee. Who is it to be? If there is no one to decide, we'll end up
with a Tower of Babel where, for example, the same method will have
different names in adjoining villages for no other reason that they rang
it first under their own village name. e.g., Oxton Doubles is called
Woodborough or Calverton or Farnsfield because they also rang it there.
Or, is it better if someone goes to the far north of the country and,
when asked to get hold for Cambridge, they know what they are being
asked to do? Someone has to decide.
As regards polls, how many people are on this theory line?
More information about the ringing-theory