[r-t] 1-part tenors together atw compositions of 23-splicedmajor

John Camp camp at bellringers.org
Thu Dec 3 13:28:29 UTC 2015

At 13:10 on 03 December 2015, John Harrison wrote:

> In article <A2AF536A8BAD407B84D9AC03D30586BC at Modak>,
>    Philip Earis <pje24 at cantab.net> wrote:

>> I'm a bit puzzled by the attitude to keep compositions secret until
>> they've been pealed. Timely publishing is beneficial to a field - this
>> is certainly the case in science, where publishing is very well
>> established ...

> Is science a valid analogy?  There the papers are published after the
> experiment has been conducted and the results obtained?

This seems to suggest that ringing a composition might be found to
invalidate it.

John Camp

More information about the ringing-theory mailing list