[r-t] Cambridge S Minor

[edward martin]

You wouldn't call it 'Grandsire' would you?
Surely a plain lead of Grandsire has 3rds made AFTER the primary hunt
has lead, not before?
My point has always been that it is NOT Grandsire but is a form of
Reverse Grandsire (which is already defined as something different!)
ie it's backwards Grandsire innit?
mew

On 10/9/06, Philip Saddleton <pabs at cantab.net> wrote:
> edward martin said  on 09/10/2006 18:01:
> > I'm afraid that this brings up (for me) an old chestnut:
> > Please consider the following:
> > Plain lead:
> > 12345
> > 21435
> > 24153
> > 42513
> > 45231
> > 54321
> > 53412
> > 35142
> > 31524
> > 13542
> > 15324
> >
> > Tony Smith maintains that this is merely Grandsire but with 3 as the
> > primary hunt & 1 as the secondary hunt; However, I maintain that if :
> > Bobbed lead:
> > 12345
> > 21354
> > 23145
> > 32415
> > 34251
> > 43521
> > 45312
> > 54132
> > 51423
> > 15432
> > 14523
> > Then clearly it is NOT !
> >
> > (I bring this up about every 5 years or so, to no avail)
> >
> > mew
>
> By the same reasoning, is this a different method?
>
> Plain lead:
>
> 12345
> 21354
> 23145
> 32415
> 34251
> 43521
> 45312
> 54132
> 51423
> 15243
> 12534
>
> Bobbed lead:
> 12345
> 21354
> 23145
> 32154
> 31245
> 13425
> 14352
> 41532
> 45123
> 54213
> 52431
>
> Philip
>
>
>
> --
> Regards
> Philip
> http://www.saddleton.freeuk.com/
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> ringing-theory mailing list
> ringing-theory at bellringers.net
> http://bellringers.net/mailman/listinfo/ringing-theory_bellringers.net
>