[r-t] Ben Constant's Yorkshire Royal

[Philip Earis]

Marky:
"...what I am saying is that the composition is Keith's...Ben's version is 
an arrangement, nothing more...I would therefore use...Arr. Ben Constant 
from Keith Scudamore"

It's a tricky one - where do you draw the line? I think with your approach 
you could get into difficulties, especially with peals of spliced.

Eg is Chandler's 23-spliced a simple re-arrangement of Smith's 23 spliced? 
Are they identical even? Would you refer to either as Arr. from trad?