[r-t] What is a 'regular' method
matthew at frye.org.uk
Mon Feb 6 17:13:30 UTC 2012
On 6 Feb 2012, at 07:26, Alex Hunt wrote:
> Criteria 5 & 6 might benefit from an exception for lead heads.
> Plain Bob at odd stages should be saved from being "irregular!.
Well, I think this (and the rest of the thread) shows the utter futility of attempting to set in stone what is "regular". It also shows the futility of trying to set a single set of rules (for anything) that apply equally well across many stages/types of method.
Plain bob triples is *obviously* a regular method, but I don't think many would think of surprise minor methods with 4 blows in one position as regular.
I think you are really best describing precisely what you mean by regular each time you use it unless it is obvious from context, eg "41 regular surprise minor".
More information about the ringing-theory