[r-t] False composition ?
andrew_johnson at uk.ibm.com
Tue Aug 27 10:08:30 UTC 2013
"ringing-theory" <ringing-theory-bounces at bellringers.net> wrote on
> From: Roddy Horton
> I wonder if anyone can help me please.
> I have just finished trawling though the Ringing Worlds between 1911
> and 1940 and have been extracting compositions of spliced.
> I have finished proving all of those that are Spliced Surprise and
> these are ready to go onto my website and into the spliced
> database. This should mean that my website rrhorton.net will include
> all compositions of spliced surprise that have been
> published in the RW, plus some that have not.
> There is one composition that baffles me.
> It is by A G Driver and was published on page 556 of the RW of 1937.
> It appears to be false within a method called Loughborough in leads
> 3 and 31. The peal was rung in May of that year and I
> cannot find the peal being withdrawn or the composition being
> amended. The method Loughborough was new at that time but the
> figures were published and agree with the method of that name on the
> current Council website. I append the composition and the
> place notation of the methods and would appreciate any guidance
> before I exclude it from the collection.
> 5472 Spliced Surprise Major (7 methods)
> A G Driver 1937 p556
> 23456 W B M H Methods
> 64235 - - - A/BCDEF/G/
> 26435 - ABCDEFG/
> 42635 - ABCDEFG/
> 63425 - - A/BCDEFG/
> 46325 - ABCDEFG/
> 34625 - ABCDEFG/
> 34256 - - A/BCD/DEFG
> 23645 - - A/BCDEF/G
> 3 part.
> Lead 3C is false against lead 31C.
Those methods look familiar from seeing a peal board on a visit
last week to Wigston Magna.
Is this the performance of the peal?
2 2D4-110 FALSE 12 May 1937 Spliced Surprise Major (7 methods)
RW 1365.0329 - False (R R Horton)
There's also this:
42 2D4-01E OK 11 May 1957 Spliced Surprise Major (7 methods)
but I can't remember the details about the date on the peal board.
Unless stated otherwise above:
IBM United Kingdom Limited - Registered in England and Wales with number
Registered office: PO Box 41, North Harbour, Portsmouth, Hampshire PO6 3AU
More information about the ringing-theory