[r-t] Method extension

Philip Saddleton pabs at cantab.net
Sun Apr 26 20:06:57 UTC 2015

On 24/04/2015 16:18, Philip Saddleton wrote:
> On Thu, April 23, 2015 19:47, Philip Earis wrote:
>> I'd
>> particularly like to see examples with these methods:
Various examples attached with some of the corresponding places at 
different stages marked.
>> - An oft-rung treble-dodging minor method...lets say London Surprise
>> Minor
> There is an extension with PB lead heads to all even stages if you don't
> require external places to remain external:
> &36-,2
That should be

example 1

> A more interesting example is Cambridge Minor, where possible
> constructions include
> Cambridge
> Lincolnshire
> Yorkshire 8, Albanian 10, Southwark 12 etc.
> Pudsey 8, Solihull 10 etc.
example 2
>> - A vanilla TD major method...Superlative, say
> Extends to 12, 16 etc.
example 3

Note that under the existing Decision this requires construction ABCD 
mode 3 above the treble, i.e. the 6th's place made when the treble is in 
4-5 in Maximus corresponds to the 2nd's at the lead head in Major (in 
construction BCDE 10th's would be made). This seems at odds with the 
fact that the method basically consists of Cambridge places everywhere, 
with alternative cross-sections having 1 or 3 made below the treble and 
the equivalent above.
>> - A simple plain method - something like St Clement's Minor (or indeed St
>> Simon's doubles)
> St Clement's
> Ashbourne College
example 4
>> - Inarguably intuitive extensions at any stage, which the current CC
>> rules nevertheless massively fail with...let's say the method where the
>> treble simply plain hunts to (n-1)th place, and similarly Ashford.
> Ok. In these cases a worked example would be more useful as an extension
> by an odd number of stages is possible and places initially in the same
> change extend differently. Other cases where extension by an odd number of
> stages is possible are:
> Original
> Duffield Major to Caters:
> Saturn Doubles to Major: 36-36.18
example 5
> 34.14.12 to 3.145.125
also Shipway Place Doubles to Single Cumberland Place Minor

example 6

Note that Reverse Canterbury Place is Minimus is not part of this 
construction as there is no place corresponding to the 5th's at the lead 
head in Doubles.

-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: examples.zip
Type: application/x-zip-compressed
Size: 88029 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://bellringers.net/pipermail/ringing-theory/attachments/20150426/d00cdd55/attachment-0001.bin>

More information about the ringing-theory mailing list