[r-t] 5184 Original Major by Giles B Thompson

[Graham John]

Has anyone checked the composition of Original Major by Giles Thompson on
page 10 of Composition 500 (first printing)? Unless I have misinterpreted
it or it is misprinted, it is false, coming round in the part starting
13425678. This isn't mentioned in the errata.

Graham

5184 Original Major
Composed by Giles B Thompson
12345678 3458
431256 2 s
241356 3 –
412356 2
351246 – – –
13524678 –
231546 2 –
521346 3 –
215346 2
341526 – – –
13452678 –
531426 2 –
451326 3 –
514326 2
321456 – – –
13245678 –
421356 2 s
351246 s 3 –
513246 2
241356 – – –
12435678 –
321456 2 –
431256 3 –
314256 2
251436 – – –
12543678 –
421536 2 –
541236 3 –
415236 2
231546 – – –
12354678 –
531246 2 s
251346 3 –
512346 2
341256 – – –
13425678 –
231456 2 –
421356 3 –
214356 2
351426 – – –
13542678 –
431526 2 –
541326 3 –
415326 2
321546 – – –
13254678 –
521346 2 s
341256 s 3 –
413256 2
251346 – – –
12534678 –
321546 2 –
531246 3 –
315246 2
241536 – – –
12453678 –
521436 2 –
451236 3 –
514236 2
231456 – – –
12345786 – –
431257 2 s
241357 3 –
412357 2
351247 – – –
13524786 –
231547 2 –
521347 3 –
215347 2
341527 – – –
13452786 –
531427 2 –
451327 3 –
514327 2
321457 – – –
13245786 –
421357 2 s
351247 s 3 –
513247 2
241357 – – –
12435786 –
321457 2 –
431257 3 –
314257 2
251437 – – –
12543786 –
421537 2 –
541237 3 –
415237 2
231547 – – –
12354786 –
531247 2 s
251347 3 –
512347 2
341257 – – –
13425786 –
231457 2 –
421357 3 –
214357 2
351427 – – –
13542786 –
431527 2 –
541327 3 –
415327 2
321547 – – –
13254786 –
521347 2 s
341257 s 3 –
413257 2
251347 – – –
12534786 –
321547 2 –
531247 3 –
315247 2
241537 – – –
12453786 –
521437 2 –
451237 3 –
514237 2
231457 – – –
12345867 – –
431258 2 s
241358 3 –
412358 2
351248 – – –
13524867 –
231548 2 –
521348 3 –
215348 2
341528 – – –
13452867 –
531428 2 –
451328 3 –
514328 2
321458 – – –
13245867 –
421358 2 s
351248 s 3 –
513248 2
241358 – – –
12435867 –
321458 2 –
431258 3 –
314258 2
251438 – – –
12543867 –
421538 2 –
541238 3 –
415238 2
231548 – – –
12354867 –
531248 2 s
251348 3 –
512348 2
341258 – – –
13425867 –
231458 2 –
421358 3 –
214358 2
351428 – – –
13542867 –
431528 2 –
541328 3 –
415328 2
321548 – – –
13254867 –
521348 2 s
341258 s 3 –
413258 2
251348 – – –
12534867 –
321548 2 –
531248 3 –
315248 2
241538 – – –
12453867 –
521438 2 –
451238 3 –
514238 2
231458 – – –
12345678 – –
Composition is false.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://bellringers.net/pipermail/ringing-theory_bellringers.net/attachments/20160120/a80fd83c/attachment-0002.html>