[r-t] PB7 Calling Positions

Martin Cansdale mjclists at gmail.com
Fri Aug 4 19:59:16 UTC 2006

> You miss the point. The view being put forward was that there should be a
> one-to-one correspondance between the name of a calling position and its
> effect upon coursing order otherwise chaos/end of the world/lost
> peals/unhappiness would ensue. My example illustrates that one calling
> position name can have two CO effects even within major without this causing
> problems.

A single middle in Cambridge does a different thing to a bob middle in
Yorkshire, but I'd still call them both middles.  I don't think
comparing different calls is a good argument against maintaining
uniformity in the effects of a fourths place bob at wrong.


More information about the ringing-theory mailing list