[r-t] Methods Committee proposed change 3.0(D)

Mark Davies mark at snowtiger.net
Wed Mar 22 00:05:26 UTC 2017

Don writes,

> This sentence, as written, appears to trump sections 5(a) and 5(b), below,
> and disallow plenty of currently legal peals of doubles and minor (and
> minimus and doubles, though I think those are less frequently rung in
> practice). If it doesn't overrule them it certainly conflicts with them,
> which is also Not A Good Idea.

Possibly; but isn't this easily corrected by, for example:

"16. A peal shall comprise true changes. This means that none of the 
possible rows for each effective stage shall appear more than once more 
than any other of the possible rows. The effective stages for different 
categories of peals are defined in section 5 below."


More information about the ringing-theory mailing list